Skip to content
HelpfulCoin

Is Sherlock Legit and Safe for Smart-Contract Audits?

Sherlock is a Web3 security company offering smart-contract audits, audit contests, AI-assisted reviews and bug bounties. It is a service for project teams, not a consumer app for depositing crypto.

Researched and written by the HelpfulCoin teamChecked 9 questions answered

The short answer

Sherlock may suit protocol teams looking for smart-contract audits, contests or bug-bounty support, but it is not a consumer crypto app. Its range of security services and published audit reports are useful, while its prices and some details about ownership and independent verification are not public. Even a strong audit cannot guarantee safe code, so check the engagement scope and treat the report as one layer of security.

Our verdict:Good, with caveats6.5/10

HelpfulCoin report card

Good, with caveats

6.5/ 10 overall

Worth using if the caveats below don’t affect you.

SafetyHow funds are held, audits, licence, incidents.
C (6.0 out of 10)
CostsFees, spreads, gas, house edge and bonus terms. Higher is cheaper.
– (not graded)
Ease of useHow easy it is for a newcomer to start, use and withdraw.
C (6.0 out of 10)
ReputationHow established and openly run it is.
B (7.0 out of 10)

Grades: A 8.5+, B 7+, C 5.5+, D 4+, F below 4. A dash means the project doesn't publish enough to grade it.

Sherlock at a glance

What it is
Web3 security and smart-contract review company
Services
Audits, contests, AI reviews and bug bounties
Token
None
Consumer deposits
Not a deposit or investment app
Pricing
No public rate card
Chains
Ethereum
Value locked
$227K−0.0% 7d
Audits
2 audits listed
Last checked

Green flags and red flags

Reassuring

  • Sherlock publishes audit reports and security research for readers to examine.
  • Its services cover code review before launch as well as bug bounties for live systems.
  • The company describes audits, contests, AI-assisted review and bug-bounty work as separate offerings.

Be careful about

  • Sherlock does not publish standard audit prices or payment terms.
  • An audit cannot guarantee that a contract is safe or catch every vulnerability.
  • Sherlock’s headline performance figures are company claims, not independent proof of security.

What is Sherlock and what does it do?

Sherlock is a Web3 security company that reviews smart-contract code and offers security services before and after launch. Its current offerings include private collaborative audits, open audit contests, AI-assisted reviews through Audit Engine, and bug bounties for live code. Protocols, infrastructure teams and institutions can hire Sherlock for one service or combine several across a project’s lifecycle. This is a service for organisations building onchain systems, not a crypto wallet or app for individual users to deposit money into. Sherlock’s homepage also describes protection and post-launch security, but it does not provide consumer insurance terms or a claims process. An audit can help find vulnerabilities; it cannot guarantee that a contract is safe or prevent every exploit.

Is Sherlock safe to use for a smart-contract audit?

Sherlock does not hold customer deposits for its audit services, so the main risk is relying too heavily on a security review—not losing funds held in a Sherlock account. An audit is a point-in-time assessment, not a guarantee: code can change after review, and auditors may miss flaws. Sherlock’s site provides audit reports and describes its security services, but it does not publish a financial-services licence, an independent audit of Sherlock itself, or a clear record of security incidents involving its own systems. The homepage says Sherlock has protected more than $250 billion in TVL and uncovered over 2,000 critical issues; those are company claims, not proof that every reviewed protocol is safe. Treat an audit as one part of a wider security process.

Is Sherlock a legitimate smart-contract security company?

Sherlock presents itself as an active security company serving protocols, financial institutions and infrastructure teams. Its homepage cites work involving Aave, Sky and the Ethereum Foundation, and says it has more than 1,500 audits or security reviews and 11,000 registered researchers. Those figures and customer endorsements are useful signs of activity, but they are company-published claims; the homepage does not give a founding date, name a full leadership team, or provide independent verification of every headline metric. Sherlock publishes security research and audit reports, which lets prospective clients examine examples of its work. The brand is therefore more than an anonymous token project, but the public information supplied here is not enough to assess its complete ownership or long-term track record independently.

How much does a Sherlock audit or bug bounty cost?

Sherlock does not publish standard prices for its audits, contests, Audit Engine reviews or bug-bounty services. The homepage directs prospective clients to contact its team, so costs may depend on the codebase, scope, timing and type of review, but Sherlock does not provide a public rate card or fee formula. Ask for a written proposal that spells out what code and versions are in scope, the review dates, deliverables, payment schedule, and how follow-up fixes are handled. For a bug bounty, check the reward pool, eligible contracts, severity rules and payout conditions before launch. Do not assume that a review’s price includes continuing monitoring or post-launch coverage unless the contract says so.

How does a Sherlock smart-contract audit work?

Sherlock’s process depends on the service a project chooses. For a private collaborative audit, its homepage says a curated team of security researchers reviews the code. Audit contests invite multiple auditors to compete to find vulnerabilities, while Audit Engine coordinates AI-based security analysis. Bug bounties invite researchers to report flaws in live code, with Sherlock’s in-house team handling triage. To begin, a project team can contact Sherlock, agree on the scope and commercial terms, then provide the relevant code and documentation. Review the resulting report and make sure fixes are checked before deployment. No audit method catches every possible issue, and an assessment only covers the agreed scope and code version; changes made later may need another review.

Can you deposit money into Sherlock or withdraw from it?

You do not deposit or withdraw crypto through Sherlock as an individual user. Its current offering is security work for project teams, not a retail investment account or exchange. A client would arrange payment for an engagement under a commercial agreement, but Sherlock does not publish standard payment methods, payment limits, withdrawal rules or settlement times. Researchers who take part in contests or bug bounties may receive rewards under the terms of the particular programme; check that programme’s eligibility and payout conditions directly before participating. Do not send funds to a wallet address claiming to be Sherlock unless the company has verified the arrangement through an official channel and the payment terms are documented.

Before you deposit: a quick checklist

  • Get a written scope, price and payment schedule before commissioning a review.
  • Check the exact code version and contracts covered by the audit report.
  • For a bounty, read eligibility, severity and reward-payout terms before submitting a finding.
  • Treat audit results as one security measure, not a guarantee against exploits.

4 steps

How to get started with Sherlock

  1. 1

    Choose whether your project needs a private audit, contest, AI-assisted review or bug bounty.

  2. 2

    Contact Sherlock and request a written proposal covering scope, fees, timing and deliverables.

  3. 3

    Confirm the exact code version and contracts in scope before the review starts.

  4. 4

    Review findings, implement fixes and arrange follow-up checks before deploying or changing code.

Plain English

Jargon explained

Smart-contract audit
A structured review of contract code to find security flaws before or after launch.
Audit contest
A review where multiple researchers compete to find vulnerabilities in a codebase.
Bug bounty
A public or private programme that rewards researchers for responsibly reporting bugs in live code.

Quick answers about Sherlock

Does Sherlock have a token?

No. Sherlock says it has no token, and its security services are not a token investment product.

Does Sherlock only work with Ethereum projects?

Sherlock works on onchain systems across different networks. Ethereum appears in its project classification, but its homepage describes a broader service and cites work on systems beyond Ethereum.

Does Sherlock offer insurance to individual crypto users?

No. Sherlock’s current services are security reviews and related work, not a retail insurance policy with published coverage terms or a consumer claims process.

Compare

Sherlock alternatives

All alternatives
Hats.V2 logo

Hats.V2

Security

Score 5.2 out of 10

Hats.V2 is an onchain bug-bounty platform, but missing audit, fee, and withdrawal details mean users should check each program carefully.

TVL $153K−0.5%Arbitrum · Ethereum · Polygon +2

Quick Intel

Security

Score 5.8 out of 10

Quick Intel scans crypto tokens and supplies security APIs; it is useful for risk signals, but those checks are not guarantees.

Base · Ethereum
Xaudits logo

Xaudits

Security

Score 6.1 out of 10

xAudits audits Solidity and Rust smart contracts and publishes reports, but its prices and auditor credentials are not public.

Ethereum · Base · Solana +3
Bicscan logo

Bicscan

Security

Score 6.0 out of 10

BICScan scans blockchain addresses and dApps for risk; its free tier is useful, but scores are not guarantees.

Ethereum · Polygon · BNB Chain
Mimir logo

Mimir

Security

Score 5.5 out of 10

Project Mimir is a self-hosted endpoint security platform; its design is promising, but independent security and operator details are limited.

Supremacy logo

Supremacy

Security

Score 5.2 out of 10

Supremacy is a blockchain security firm; its security research claims are notable, but verify its team, methods and pricing before hiring.

Same category

More Security dApps

Security rankings
Quantstamp Security Network logoScore 6.2 out of 10

Quantstamp is a Web3 security firm offering audits and related services; consider it, but treat audits as limited reviews, not safety guarantees.

Hawk Finance logo

Hawk Finance

Security

Score 5.8 out of 10

Hawk is enterprise AML and fraud software, not a crypto investment app; it may suit institutions, but buyers should verify security and pricing.

Nixguard logo

Nixguard

Security

Score 5.8 out of 10

NixGuard is compliance-preparation and endpoint-monitoring software; its free plan is worth exploring, but check data security and extra audit costs first.

Quillcheck

Security

Score 5.8 out of 10

QuillCheck scans webpage URLs for likely AI-written text; it is easy to try, but its scores are estimates and privacy details are limited.

Base
Mint Message logo

Mint Message

Security

Score 5.7 out of 10

Mint Message appears to refer to DigitalMint, a ransomware-response firm; it may suit organizations, but verify fees and crypto custody first.

Securedapp logo

Securedapp

Security

Score 5.7 out of 10

SecureDApp offers Web3 audits and security tools, but verify its work, fees and asset-handling terms before hiring or connecting a wallet.

Same chain

More on Ethereum

Ethereum rankings
Uniswap V3 logoScore 7.2 out of 10

Uniswap V3 is a wallet-based decentralized exchange; it is worth a look, but swaps and liquidity positions carry on-chain risks.

TVL $1.30B−11.9%Ethereum · Base · Arbitrum +38
Lido logo

Lido

Staking Pool

Score 7.1 out of 10

Lido stakes ETH for liquid stETH; it is a substantial protocol, but returns and instant exit are not guaranteed.

TVL $17.9B−13.0%Ethereum · Solana · Terra +2
Aave V3 logo

Aave V3

Lending

Score 7.1 out of 10

Aave V3 is a multi-chain crypto lending protocol; its long track record and audits are reassuring, but borrowing and smart-contract risks remain.

TVL $14.0B−8.2%Ethereum · Base · Arbitrum +18
Uniswap V2 logoScore 7.1 out of 10

Uniswap V2 is a non-custodial token-swap protocol with a long track record, but trades and liquidity positions carry smart-contract and market risks.

TVL $720M−13.4%Ethereum · Base · Polygon +14
Ethereum Finance logoScore 7.1 out of 10

Ethereum is a public blockchain for ETH and smart-contract apps; it is worth exploring, but wallet and app risks remain.

Ethereum
Uniswap logo

Uniswap

DEXes

Score 7.1 out of 10

Uniswap is a long-running wallet-based exchange for crypto swaps, worth a look if you understand smart-contract and transaction risks.

Ethereum · Base · Arbitrum +2

Where the answers come from

Sources

  1. defillama.com/protocol/sherlock(opens in a new tab)

Last checked . Something wrong or out of date? Let us know and we will fix it.