Comparison · Updated
Hats.V2 vs Sherlock: Which Security Platform Should You Use?
Choose Hats.V2 to create or join onchain bug bounties and security competitions; choose Sherlock if a project needs professional smart-contract reviews, contests or bounty services. Neither is a general-purpose crypto app for earning guaranteed returns.
Sherlock
Security
TVL $227K · 1 chains
Side by side
Hats.V2 vs Sherlock at a glance
| Hats.V2 | Sherlock | |
|---|---|---|
| Category | Onchain bug-bounty and security-competition platform | Web3 security company offering audits, contests, AI reviews and bug bounties |
| Chains | Arbitrum, Ethereum, Polygon, BNB Chain and Optimism | Ethereum |
| TVL | TVL figure is not date-stamped; check the current value before relying on it | TVL figure is not date-stamped; it is not a consumer deposit product |
| Token | No current token established; token reward status is unclear | No token |
| Fees | Full fee schedule and withdrawal conditions are not published | No public rate card; engagement pricing is arranged with Sherlock |
| Security and audits | No audits listed; liquidity provision carries smart-contract risk | Two audits listed; Sherlock publishes work reports, but an audit is not a safety guarantee |
| Ease of use | Requires understanding each bounty’s rules and, for liquidity, onchain transactions | Teams need to scope and arrange a commercial security engagement |
| Standout feature | Permissionless liquidity can help fund onchain bounty rewards | Combines private audits, contests, AI-assisted reviews and bug-bounty support |
| Best for | Projects coordinating onchain rewards and researchers assessing specific bounty programs | Protocol teams seeking code reviews or structured security programs |
| Deposits | Liquidity providers can deposit to a bounty vault; verify terms and contract addresses first | Not a consumer deposit or investment app |
Which is safer to use?
Sherlock has more visible audit credentials, but neither option is risk-free, and they carry different kinds of risk. Hats.V2 has no audits listed, and providing liquidity exposes funds to smart-contract vulnerabilities as well as the rules of a specific bounty or vault. Onchain activity does not guarantee that funds can be withdrawn when expected.
Sherlock publishes audit reports and has two audits listed, but that should not be confused with an audit of Sherlock’s own systems. Its core risk for a client is relying too heavily on a code review: an audit can miss flaws, and code may change after review. For a project choosing a security provider, inspect relevant reports and define the scope. For a researcher, read the bounty rules. For a liquidity provider, check the exact contract and withdrawal terms before sending funds.
Which one is cheaper?
Neither can be called cheaper from public standard pricing, because neither publishes a complete, comparable price schedule. Hats.V2 does not publish a full fee schedule, so a project or liquidity provider should check the terms of the particular competition or vault. Onchain transactions may also require network gas, which varies by chain and network conditions.
Sherlock does not publish a standard rate card for audits, contests, AI-assisted reviews or bug bounties. A project should request a written proposal covering scope, deliverables, payment terms and any follow-up work. These are different products as well as different pricing models: Hats.V2 coordinates onchain bounty funding, while Sherlock sells security services to teams. Compare the total cost for the same defined outcome rather than assuming one is cheaper based on its product category.
Which is easier for a beginner?
Sherlock is usually the clearer fit for a project team that wants to commission a security review, while Hats.V2 may suit someone comfortable evaluating onchain bounty rules. Sherlock’s process begins with choosing a service and agreeing on scope and commercial terms. Its offerings include private collaborative audits, open contests, AI-assisted reviews and bug bounties, so the team still needs to decide which kind of review it needs.
Hats.V2 is aimed at projects creating onchain bounties and researchers deciding whether to report eligible vulnerabilities. Each program can set its own scope, submission requirements and reward rules. Liquidity provision adds another layer: users need to understand the vault and withdrawal conditions, not just the bounty description. Neither is a simple consumer app for depositing money and receiving a predictable return. A beginner should avoid depositing funds until the relevant terms and risks are understood.
What can each one do that the other cannot?
Hats.V2 offers permissionless, onchain coordination and liquidity for security bounties; Sherlock offers a broader menu of security services for project teams. Hats.V2’s distinct use is letting projects organize bounties or competitions and letting users contribute liquidity to a bounty. Researchers can review individual programs and submit findings that meet their rules. It is not a general-purpose exchange or guaranteed source of income.
Sherlock’s distinct use is combining different ways to assess or monitor smart-contract security: private audits, competitive contests, AI-assisted reviews and bug bounties for live code. This makes it relevant to teams looking for structured security work across development and after launch. Sherlock is not a retail app for users to deposit crypto. Choose based on the task: onchain bounty coordination points toward Hats.V2; commissioned code review or a broader security engagement points toward Sherlock.
Verdict: Hats.V2 or Sherlock?
Hats.V2 and Sherlock serve different needs, so the better choice depends on whether the goal is to coordinate an onchain bounty or hire security professionals. Hats.V2 supports bounties, competitions and optional liquidity provision, but no audits are listed and its fees and withdrawal terms need checking. Sherlock offers audits, contests, AI-assisted reviews and bug bounties for project teams, but does not publish standard prices. Neither an audit nor an onchain setup guarantees safety.
Choose Hats.V2 if you need onchain bounty coordination or want to assess specific researcher programs. Choose Sherlock if your project needs a scoped security review or related services.
Frequently asked questions
Can individual users deposit crypto into Sherlock?
No. Sherlock provides security services to project teams; it is not an investment account or consumer deposit app. Researchers may earn rewards through specific contests or bug bounties, subject to each program’s rules.
Can you earn a return by providing liquidity on Hats.V2?
Hats.V2 supports liquidity provision for bounties, but that involves smart-contract and withdrawal risks. No audits are listed for Hats.V2, and current fees and withdrawal terms are not fully published, so verify the specific vault before depositing.
Which one is cheaper?
Neither publishes a standard public rate card. Hats.V2’s full fee schedule is not published, while Sherlock asks prospective clients to discuss pricing for the specific service.
Does a Sherlock audit guarantee a smart contract is safe?
No. An audit is a review of code, not a guarantee that it has no flaws. Code can change after review, and vulnerabilities can be missed, so audits should be one part of a broader security process.