Comparison · Updated
Concrete vs Makina: Which DeFi Vault Platform Fits You in 2026?
Concrete is the broader choice for users comparing curated vaults across more networks; Makina is geared toward users choosing operator-run Machines on Ethereum or Base. Neither is a low-risk or fully transparent option, so review each vault’s terms before depositing.
Concrete
Onchain Capital Allocator
TVL $1.05B · 5 chains
Makina
Onchain Capital Allocator
TVL $38.5M · 2 chains
Side by side
Concrete vs Makina at a glance
| Concrete | Makina | |
|---|---|---|
| Category | Onchain capital allocator offering curated yield vaults | Onchain vault and execution infrastructure for strategy operators |
| Chains | Ethereum, Stable, Arbitrum, Berachain, Katana | Ethereum, Base |
| TVL | Not published with a dated figure | Not published with a dated figure |
| Token | CT; utility beyond claiming or staking features is unclear | No token identified |
| Fees | No full fee schedule published; check each vault | No platform-wide fee schedule published; check each Machine |
| Security and audits | Two audits noted; vault pages name firms including Halborn and Cantina, but coverage varies | Two audits noted; scope and dates are unclear |
| Ease of use | Vault-by-vault choices; some are permissioned and some show withdrawal queues | Choose a Machine and review its operator, strategy and terms |
| Standout feature | Curated yield vaults across five networks | Onchain strategy execution infrastructure, including cross-chain execution |
| Best for | Experienced DeFi users seeking curated vault options across several chains | Experienced users choosing operator-run strategies on Ethereum or Base |
Which should you use, Concrete or Makina?
Concrete is the better fit if you want to compare curated vaults across several networks; Makina is a closer fit if you want to select an operator-run Machine on Ethereum or Base. Concrete presents yield vaults to depositors directly, although some are permissioned or keep APY private. Makina provides infrastructure for strategy operators, with each Machine representing a particular strategy and its operator. Neither is a general-purpose savings account: yields can change, and strategy losses are possible.
The practical choice depends on the specific product, not just the platform name. Compare the asset accepted, strategy, access rules, fee terms, audit information and withdrawal process for the vault or Machine you are considering. If those details are unclear, or the risk is hard to assess, neither platform is a good place to deposit money you may need soon.
Which is safer, Concrete or Makina?
Neither can be called safer overall; both involve smart-contract and strategy risks, and each product needs its own review. Concrete names auditors such as Halborn and Cantina on some vault pages, but audit coverage varies and it does not publish one complete audit record for every vault. Some vaults also describe wallet controls using providers such as Fordefi or Fireblocks. Those controls do not prevent every contract, strategy or operator failure.
Makina describes its model as non-custodial and says strategy mandates and risk parameters are enforced onchain. It lists two audits, but does not publish their scope or dates. Non-custodial means assets are managed through onchain contracts rather than a conventional exchange account; it does not prevent losses from contract bugs, bad strategies, protocol failures or cross-chain execution. Makina also mentions coverage powered by Nexus Mutual without explaining which Machines qualify or the limits. Treat audits and controls as safeguards, not guarantees.
Which is cheaper, Concrete or Makina?
Neither can be reliably called cheaper because neither publishes a platform-wide fee schedule. Concrete’s fees may vary by vault, while a Makina Machine may have operator or strategy charges. A missing fee figure does not mean the fee is zero, so look for how any management or performance charge is calculated and when it applies before depositing.
Both also involve blockchain gas fees for transactions. Makina’s cross-chain execution may add steps or costs, depending on the Machine and networks involved. Concrete’s vaults can likewise use different strategies and partner protocols, which may affect net returns. Compare expected returns only after accounting for fees and other costs, and remember that displayed APY is not guaranteed. If a product’s fee terms are not clear enough to estimate the cost, pause rather than assuming it is inexpensive.
Which is easier for a beginner?
Neither is an ideal first DeFi product for someone who has not used wallets, token approvals and onchain transactions before. Concrete may be somewhat easier to scan as a vault platform, but users still need to assess individual strategies, permission requirements and withdrawal queues. Makina asks users to choose among Machines run by different operators, so understanding each mandate and its risk settings matters.
Both require care with wallet prompts and network selection. A wallet connection does not by itself deposit funds, but token approvals and transactions can authorize actions onchain. Keep enough of the relevant network’s native token for gas, confirm the asset and network, and do not deposit until the exit terms are understood. A beginner who cannot evaluate the strategy, fees or withdrawal conditions should consider learning with lower-risk activities before using either platform.
What can Concrete do that Makina cannot, and vice versa?
Concrete stands out for offering curated yield vaults across five named networks, while Makina stands out for providing execution infrastructure for operator-run strategies called Machines. Concrete’s broader chain coverage may give users more vault and network combinations to investigate, but availability and access differ by vault. Some Concrete products are permissioned, and some do not show a public APY.
Makina’s distinctive approach is to package strategies into Machines and use onchain mandates and risk parameters to constrain some operator actions. Its documentation also describes cross-chain execution. Those features do not mean every Machine uses the same strategy, risk limits or withdrawal terms. In either case, the user is choosing exposure to a particular strategy, not simply choosing a platform. Read the specific product’s documents and check who operates it, what assets it uses and how withdrawals work before committing funds.
Verdict: Concrete or Makina?
Concrete is the more natural choice if you want curated vaults across a wider range of networks. Makina is better suited to experienced users who want to compare operator-run Machines on Ethereum or Base and value its onchain strategy controls. Neither publishes a platform-wide fee schedule or general withdrawal terms, and neither removes the risk of contract bugs, strategy losses or delays. Check the exact product’s fees, access rules, audit details and withdrawal process before depositing. Choose Concrete if you want more chain options; choose Makina if its Machine-based operator model fits your needs.
Frequently asked questions
Which has more supported chains?
Concrete offers vaults across Ethereum, Stable, Arbitrum, Berachain and Katana; Makina supports Ethereum and Base. A network being supported does not mean every vault or asset is available on it.
Are Concrete or Makina cheaper?
Neither publishes a platform-wide fee schedule, general withdrawal timing or limits. Check the specific vault or Machine for its fees, supported assets and exit conditions, and account for network gas.
Are Concrete and Makina safe?
Concrete’s vaults and Makina’s Machines both carry smart-contract and strategy risks. Concrete names audit firms on some vaults, while Makina describes onchain risk controls and a non-custodial design; neither makes deposits risk-free.
Do Concrete and Makina have tokens?
Neither has a clearly identified token in common: Concrete has CT, while no Makina token is identified. The information given does not establish CT’s utility beyond claiming or staking features.