Comparison · Updated
Arrakis Modular vs ICHI: Which Liquidity Manager Fits You?
Arrakis Modular is the closer fit for token teams managing DEX liquidity; ICHI is designed around single-token vaults, but currently shows no available vaults. Neither is a simple, low-risk savings product.
Arrakis Modular
Liquidity Manager
TVL $47.8M · 6 chains
ICHI
Liquidity Manager
TVL $4.82M · 26 chains
Side by side
Arrakis Modular vs ICHI at a glance
| Arrakis Modular | ICHI | |
|---|---|---|
| Category | Liquidity-management framework for automated market making | Non-custodial vaults for liquidity strategies |
| Chains | Ethereum, Base, Arbitrum, Plasma, Robinhood Chain and BNB Chain | 26 networks, including Ethereum, Base, Arbitrum and Polygon |
| TVL | About $52.1M reported; date not published | About $5.4M reported; date not published |
| Token | No token specified | ICHI token; not established as necessary for vault use |
| Fees | No general fee schedule; vault and service terms vary | No complete fee schedule; check each vault's terms |
| Security and audits | Two audits recorded; reports, scope and findings not specified | Two audits recorded; check whether the specific vault is covered |
| Ease of use | Primarily for token issuers and experienced liquidity providers | Single-token vault model, but homepage currently shows zero available vaults |
| Standout feature | Modular framework for different integrations and market-making strategies | Single-token deposits deployed into liquidity strategies |
| Best for | Teams seeking automated onchain market making | DeFi users seeking single-token vaults, if a suitable vault becomes available |
| Main risk | Non-custodial design; each vault has distinct risks and exit rules | Non-custodial design; concentrated liquidity and token-price risks apply |
Which is safer, Arrakis Modular or ICHI?
Neither is automatically safer; both expose funds to smart-contract, strategy and market risks. Arrakis describes its market-making service as non-custodial, while ICHI describes its vaults as on-chain and non-custodial. That reduces reliance on a company holding assets in an ordinary account, but it does not prevent a contract bug, a strategy failure or losses when token prices move.
Two audits are recorded for each project. For Arrakis, the audit reports, scope and findings are not specified. ICHI records two audits, but the coverage of any particular live vault still needs checking. An audit is not a guarantee against loss, especially if a vault uses contracts or strategies outside the audit’s scope.
Before using either, identify the exact vault, contract, assets, permissions and withdrawal rules. Arrakis vaults can differ from one another, and ICHI’s homepage currently shows no available vaults. Do not treat the overall project’s audit count as proof that a specific deployment is protected.
Which is cheaper to use?
Neither is clearly cheaper because neither publishes a complete general fee schedule. Arrakis fees may depend on the service, strategy, pool or agreement; the terms for each vault matter. ICHI also does not publish a complete fee schedule, and fees can vary by vault.
Both may involve blockchain gas costs, paid to the network for transactions. A vault or service may also charge management, performance or withdrawal fees, so check the specific terms and transaction preview rather than assuming that the absence of a public standard rate means no charge.
The larger cost question is not just fees. Both products put assets into liquidity strategies, where price changes can affect returns or leave a position with a different token mix. Trading fees are not guaranteed to offset those losses. Compare the expected charges, withdrawal conditions and strategy risks for the exact deployment; there is no reliable overall price winner from the published fee information.
Which is easier for a beginner?
Neither is especially beginner-friendly, and ICHI’s simpler single-token deposit concept does not help if there is no live vault to use. Arrakis Modular is mainly infrastructure for token issuers and liquidity providers, not a general savings app. Its vaults can have different integrations, strategies, fees and exit rules, which require careful checking.
ICHI’s basic model is easier to describe: a user deposits one token, and a vault puts it into a liquidity strategy. But concentrated-liquidity strategies can change exposure as prices move, and withdrawals may not return the same mix or value of assets. The homepage currently shows zero available vaults, so availability needs to be verified before connecting a wallet.
A new DeFi user should understand wallet approvals, network fees, token contracts and liquidity-pool risk before using either. If the goal is a simple deposit-and-withdraw product with predictable balances, neither product is a close match.
What can each product do differently?
Arrakis Modular is distinguished by its modular framework for automated market making, while ICHI is distinguished by vaults designed for single-token deposits. Arrakis uses a shared Meta Vault structure intended to support different integrations and strategies. It is aimed mainly at token issuers and liquidity providers who need to manage onchain markets across supported exchanges.
ICHI’s vault approach lets a deposit start with one token, which is then deployed into a liquidity position. Its strategies can use concentrated liquidity: funds are assigned to a selected price range rather than spread across all prices. That can use capital more efficiently, but a market move can change the position’s exposure and value.
These are product differences, not guarantees of better returns or lower risk. Arrakis does not make every vault identical, and ICHI’s current vault availability should be checked directly. A user should compare the exact pool, strategy, contract permissions and exit conditions rather than choosing from the product description alone.
Which one should you use?
Choose Arrakis Modular if you are a token issuer or experienced liquidity provider seeking automated market making and are prepared to assess a specific vault’s terms. Its multi-chain framework supports several named networks, but there is no universal fee schedule or withdrawal policy. Verify the exact deployment, contract permissions, fees and exit rules before committing funds.
Choose ICHI if you specifically want to evaluate a single-token liquidity vault and can verify that a suitable vault is live. Its broad network support and single-token entry model may fit that use case, but the homepage currently shows zero available vaults. Its ICHI token is a separate asset, and holding it is not established as a requirement for vault use.
For a newcomer looking for a general-purpose yield account, neither is the obvious choice. Both involve onchain risks and variable outcomes, and neither guarantees a return. If a live vault’s strategy or withdrawal terms are unclear, do not deposit until they are understood.
Verdict: Arrakis Modular or ICHI?
Arrakis Modular is the more practical fit for token issuers and experienced liquidity providers seeking automated DEX market making. ICHI is built around single-token liquidity vaults, but its homepage currently shows zero available vaults, so check availability before considering it. Both are non-custodial by description, yet smart-contract, strategy and price risks remain; both also lack a complete general fee schedule.
Choose Arrakis Modular if you need configurable liquidity management and can review the specific vault’s fees and exit rules. Choose ICHI if a suitable live single-token vault is available and its strategy and contract details meet your needs.
Frequently asked questions
Is Arrakis Modular better than ICHI?
No. Both are liquidity-management products with smart-contract, strategy and market risks, and neither has a complete public fee schedule. Arrakis is more focused on project and issuer liquidity, while ICHI’s homepage currently shows no available vaults.
Which has more audits?
Both have two audits recorded, but the audit count alone does not show whether a particular vault or current contract was covered. Check the reports, scope and findings for the exact deployment before depositing.
Which one has lower fees?
Neither publishes a complete general fee schedule. Network gas costs apply, and the specific vault or service may have additional charges, so review its terms before committing funds.
Do I need to buy a token to use either product?
ICHI has an ICHI token, while Arrakis Modular has no token specified. Holding ICHI is not established as a requirement for using a vault, so check the rules of any live vault.