Skip to content
HelpfulCoin

NFT · Explainer

How Did OpenSea and Blur Compete Over NFT Royalties?

OpenSea and Blur have competed over who pays creators when NFTs resell. The dispute shows why royalties can matter to artists, traders and collectors—and why a marketplace’s fee policy does not guarantee that a creator will be paid.

By the HelpfulCoin editorial team · Updated

Illustration for How Did OpenSea and Blur Compete Over NFT Royalties?

How did OpenSea and Blur compete over NFT royalties?

OpenSea and Blur competed over NFT creator royalties by adopting different marketplace rules for whether a resale should pay the creator. A creator royalty is a fee intended for the artist or project when an NFT changes hands after its first sale. It is separate from the price paid to the seller and from blockchain transaction costs.

The debate became a major marketplace issue in 2022 and 2023. Some creators wanted royalties to keep supporting projects after minting, while traders argued that optional fees could make buying and selling cheaper. The marketplaces’ policies also influenced where collections could be traded and how much activity they attracted.

The central complication is that an NFT does not always force every later marketplace to pay a royalty. Marketplaces can choose to collect or encourage the fee, but the collection’s token contract may not be able to enforce it across every transfer. So the same NFT can have different royalty treatment on different platforms.

For a buyer or seller, the key question is not simply which marketplace supports creators. It is whether the exact transaction includes a creator fee, what other costs apply, and whether the collection has a policy that affects trading elsewhere.

What is a creator royalty, and how does it work?

An NFT creator royalty is a payment a collection creator requests when an NFT is resold, but it is not the same as a guaranteed commission on every future trade. A marketplace can include a royalty in its checkout or sale flow, and a collection may use tools intended to restrict trading that does not follow its preferred rules. Those measures do not necessarily control every marketplace or every transfer.

Royalties are usually expressed as a percentage of a sale price. The amount and recipient depend on the collection’s settings and the marketplace’s implementation. They are not the same as a marketplace fee, which the platform charges for operating its service, or a network fee, which pays for processing an on-chain transaction.

This distinction matters when comparing listings. A displayed NFT price may not show the complete amount the buyer will pay, and a seller may receive less than the sale price after applicable fees. The final transaction review is the most useful place to check the actual breakdown.

Creators may value royalties as continuing income, especially when a project expects to fund future work or community benefits. But an NFT’s royalty setting cannot ensure sales, income or long-term funding. Trading activity and marketplace policy both matter.

What was the difference between OpenSea’s and Blur’s policies?

OpenSea and Blur took different approaches to royalty enforcement, and those approaches changed as marketplaces competed for creators and traders. In 2022, OpenSea introduced tools aimed at requiring creator fees for certain new collections. In 2023, it shifted to making creator fees optional for new collections, while Blur said it would enforce full royalties for collections that blocked trading on OpenSea.

The disagreement reflected two competing priorities. Stronger royalty rules could help creators receive payments when NFTs resold, but traders could prefer marketplaces with fewer mandatory costs. Marketplace rules could also influence where a collection was allowed to trade, creating pressure for creators to choose how broadly their NFTs could be listed.

These policies are not permanent guarantees. A marketplace can revise its fee approach, and the applicable treatment can vary by collection. A past announcement does not tell a buyer what a current transaction will charge.

In 2026, check the fee and royalty terms shown for the specific NFT and marketplace before placing an order. If a collection’s creator payment matters to you, look for the collection’s stated royalty policy as well as the marketplace’s current handling of that policy.

Why do NFT royalties matter to creators and traders?

Royalties matter because they can direct part of a resale payment to the people who made or maintain an NFT collection. For some artists and projects, this was intended to support ongoing creative work, community activity or maintenance after the initial mint. A royalty can therefore affect how creators think about releasing and managing a collection.

But a royalty is only useful as income when NFTs actually sell and the fee is applied. If buyers move to venues with lower costs or avoid collections with restrictive trading rules, a creator may receive fewer royalty payments or see less trading activity. Conversely, optional fees can make a trade cheaper but reduce the chance that creators are paid on that sale.

The trade-off is not simply “good for creators” versus “good for traders.” Buyers may want to support a creator, sellers may prioritize their net proceeds, and marketplaces may compete on costs and liquidity. Different collections and users can reasonably make different choices.

Royalties also do not make an NFT a reliable investment. They do not guarantee a resale buyer, a minimum price or a continuing income stream. Treat the fee as one part of a transaction’s cost and the creator’s compensation model, not as evidence that an NFT will appreciate.

How can you compare royalty costs safely?

The marketplace with the lowest apparent fee is not automatically the better choice, because the complete cost and the NFT’s authenticity matter more than one fee line. Compare the displayed purchase price, creator royalty, marketplace charge and network fee before deciding. Costs can vary by collection, transaction and blockchain.

Use this checklist before buying or listing:

  1. Find the collection through a trusted source and verify its contract or official collection identity. Look out for copied names and artwork.
  2. Open the exact NFT and check its seller, listing price, collection details and transaction status.
  3. Review the final order screen for the total you will pay and any creator payment. Do not assume the listing price is the full cost.
  4. Check the amount you would receive as a seller after fees and royalties, if shown.
  5. Confirm the wallet is connected to the intended marketplace and inspect any requested approvals before signing.
  6. If anything differs from what you expected, cancel and investigate rather than signing quickly.

An NFT marketplace may show information that helps with a decision, but it cannot guarantee that a collection is legitimate or that its value will hold. A wallet signature can authorize an action, so read the request and avoid approving permissions you do not understand.

Can a collection enforce royalties on every NFT sale?

A royalty setting can affect who receives part of a resale payment, but it does not by itself make an NFT transferable only through one marketplace. The way the collection’s smart contract is built matters. A smart contract is software on a blockchain that can set rules for certain actions; it cannot automatically make every outside marketplace follow a policy unless the relevant system supports and applies that restriction.

Some projects have used trading restrictions or marketplace filters to encourage royalties. These tools can limit compatibility or influence which venues support the collection. They may not cover every way an NFT can change hands, and marketplace support can change. A collection’s royalty terms therefore should not be read as proof that every resale will generate payment.

For collectors, this means that a project’s stated royalty percentage is not necessarily the amount creators will receive on every sale. For creators, it means choosing a royalty policy can involve a trade-off between enforcement and broad marketplace access.

Before trading, check the collection’s own stated terms and the marketplace’s current fee display. If those do not clearly explain the amount or recipient, do not assume a royalty will be applied—or that a listed percentage is guaranteed on every transfer.

What mistakes should NFT buyers and sellers avoid?

Common mistakes include assuming that a royalty is automatic, treating the displayed NFT price as the full cost, or believing that a creator-fee policy will remain unchanged. Marketplace policies have shifted over time, so an old article or social post may not describe what a current listing charges.

Watch out for these problems:

  • Confusing fee types: A creator royalty, marketplace fee and blockchain network fee are different costs.
  • Trusting a percentage without checking the checkout: The actual fee can depend on the collection and the marketplace’s current rules.
  • Assuming a “royalty-free” trade has no costs: Other fees may still apply, and sellers may receive less than the sale price.
  • Buying a lookalike NFT: Check the collection identity, not only the name, image or floor price. A floor price is the lowest current asking price, not a guaranteed sale value.
  • Signing a wallet request without reading it: Unnecessary token or NFT approvals can create risk if granted to an unsafe contract.
  • Treating royalties as investment protection: A royalty does not ensure demand, resale liquidity or a particular price.

Pause if the collection, seller, fee breakdown or wallet request does not match expectations. A missed trade is usually less costly than an irreversible transaction sent to the wrong place.

What should you remember about OpenSea, Blur and royalties?

The OpenSea–Blur royalty dispute shows that marketplace fees are partly a matter of platform policy, not just a fixed feature of an NFT. OpenSea made creator fees optional for new collections in 2023, while Blur’s response at that time tied full royalty enforcement to collections that blocked OpenSea. The larger lesson is that rules can change and collection-specific treatment can differ.

For creators, the choice can involve deciding how strongly to encourage royalties and how much marketplace access to preserve. For traders, the useful comparison is the transaction’s complete cost, not a general claim that one platform is cheaper or more creator-friendly. For collectors, authenticity, wallet safety and the possibility of losing money remain important regardless of royalty settings.

Before using either marketplace, check its current interface and terms, verify that the collection is genuine, inspect the final transaction details, and read wallet approvals before signing. Do not rely on old policy announcements for a current trade.

No royalty arrangement guarantees income for creators or profit for buyers. NFT prices and resale demand can fall, and some NFTs may be difficult to sell. Make decisions based on what the transaction costs and what you can afford to lose.

Frequently asked questions

What are NFT creator royalties?

A creator royalty is a payment requested by an NFT creator when the NFT is resold. Whether it is paid depends on the marketplace’s rules and, in some cases, the collection’s setup.

Are NFT royalties mandatory?

No. A royalty is not automatically enforced by every NFT marketplace or transfer. Check the marketplace’s current policy and the collection’s fee settings before trading.

How did OpenSea and Blur differ on royalties?

OpenSea and Blur have used different approaches to creator fees, and those policies have changed over time. The practical difference is whether a marketplace requires, encourages or makes creator payments optional for a particular collection.

Does buying on a marketplace with lower royalties save money?

Not necessarily. A marketplace that does not charge a royalty may still charge other fees, and the NFT’s price can change for many reasons. A lower fee is not a promise of a better sale or investment result.

How can I check whether a sale includes a creator royalty?

Check the transaction screen for the total cost, including any creator fee and network fee. Also verify the collection and NFT, review wallet approvals, and make sure the payment is going to the intended seller.

Mentioned in this guide

dApps in this guide

Opensea

NFT Marketplaces: General

Score 6.6 out of 10

OpenSea is a long-running NFT marketplace, but buyers still need to check fees, wallet approvals and each collection’s authenticity.

Ethereum · Polygon · Kaia

Blur

NFT Marketplaces: General

Score 5.2 out of 10

Blur is an NFT marketplace and aggregator with a BLUR governance token; it may suit experienced traders, but key safety and fee details need checking.

Common logo

Common

Privacy

Score 5.2 out of 10

Common is a self-custodial crypto privacy app; it may be worth researching, but unclear fees and audit scope call for caution.

TVL $1.38K−10.1%Arbitrum

Keep reading

Related guides

All nft guides

NFT · Explainer

What Is the Blur Token (BLUR)?

BLUR is the governance token associated with Blur, an Ethereum NFT marketplace and trading aggregator. Learn what the token does, how it differs from an NFT, and how to approach it safely.

NFT · Best list

What Are the Best NFT Marketplaces in 2026?

The best NFT marketplace depends on the blockchain, type of NFT and wallet you want to use. Compare OpenSea, Magic Eden, Rarible, Objkt, SuperRare and Tensor by fit—not hype—and check costs, collection authenticity and wallet permissions before trading.

NFT · Explainer

Why Did OpenSea Users Surge 67% Around NFT Drops?

A 67% rise in OpenSea users around limited-edition drops would point to a burst of attention, not necessarily lasting growth or successful sales. The figure needs a time window and a clear definition of “users” before it can be interpreted; either way, drop-day buyers should verify the collection, costs and wallet requests before minting.

NFT · Explainer

What Did the $1.5B NFT Record in Q1 2021 Mean?

NFTs recorded about $1.5 billion in transaction volume in the first quarter of 2021, a striking milestone during a fast-growing market. That figure describes reported trading activity—not the amount buyers earned, the number of people involved, or a measure of today’s market.

NFT · Explainer

What Happened in the OpenSea Insider Trading Case?

A former OpenSea product manager was convicted after buying NFTs he knew the marketplace planned to feature, then had that conviction overturned on appeal. The case shows why confidential marketplace information matters—and why the legal label “insider trading” can be more complicated than it sounds.

NFT · Explainer

What Does $1 Billion in OpenSea Volume Mean?

A claim that OpenSea passed $1 billion in weekly volume describes the value of trades, not the platform’s earnings or buyers’ profits. Without a date and a clear definition of the metric, it should not be treated as a verified current record.

NFT · Explainer

What Did OpenSea’s 1,400% Growth in 2021 Mean?

OpenSea’s 2021 growth made it a defining NFT marketplace, but “1,400%” is meaningful only when you know what was measured and compared. Learn how to interpret the claim, what changed afterward, and what to check before trading NFTs in 2026.

NFT · Explainer

How Did an OpenSea Bug Affect BAYC NFT Sales?

The OpenSea incident involved old NFT listings that could remain active after owners thought they had canceled them. Learn why a BAYC might appear unusually cheap, what the bug did—and how buyers and sellers can reduce the risks.